October 21, 2026

I wish this were satire. It is not. The numbers are real, and so is everything else.

Written by Omar Nabil Metwally, MD, physician-dissident: a licensed, Internal Medicine board-certified physician with a perfectly clean malpractice record, professionally orphaned in a country without a functional healthcare system.

I. The Cover Letter

Dear United States,

Enclosed please find a final invoice. I am closing my account.

I have been meaning to write since May 2018, when I first bought health insurance from you directly, through a website, the way one buys a toaster.

I am a physician. Until recently I earned about $145,000 a year, paid my taxes early, carried no debt, and took a certain pride in all three. Then the healthcare system I had been paying into for most of my adult life messed up my right leg. I will spare you the clinical details. The short version is that I cannot afford the surgery that would fix me, and the hospital sends me bills. This month it sent one for my daughter. Forty dollars. That was the one that did it. Not the leg. The forty dollars.

I want to be clear that this is not a complaint. I am past complaining. The people are fine. Most of them are tired. The arrangement, under which I pay you, and then I pay Blue Care Network, and then, when I am sick, I pay again, is not something I am asking you to fix. Yesterday I received good news and bad news. The good news: Blue Care Network of Michigan approved a prior authorization for a hip MR arthrogram (a study that involves injecting contrast into the hip joint just before getting an MRI). Orthopedic surgeons use the results of these imaging tests to help them plan surgery. The bad news: with an $18,000 deductible, despite prior authorization, I still have to pay the cost of the study (several thousand dollars) out of pocket, in addition to my insurance premiums.

I have had some time off my feet to think about it, and I have done what one does with any subscription that has stopped working. I have cancelled it. I have already left. This is the closing statement.

I do not blame my countrymen. They do not know any better. They have been told their whole lives that the more you pay, the more you get, and since they pay more for healthcare than anyone on earth, it follows that they must be getting the most. They are not. Among the countries rich enough to run the comparison, theirs pays about twice the going rate and dies the soonest. I say this with no disrespect to anyone else’s hospitals. I say it as someone who has stood on both sides of the bed, back when I could stand without cursing in pain. The arrangement is not a healthcare system. It is a subscription to the belief that you are in one.

The invoice covers two things. First, the premiums my family paid out of pocket for Marketplace coverage, net of the credits you already applied. I have deducted those because I am not a monster. Second, the share of my federal income tax that, by your own accounting, went to health programs in the same years. I am not asking for all of my taxes back. You can keep the roads. I will not be using them. I am asking for the part that was supposed to buy a functioning healthcare system and did not. I have also added the Global Entry fee. I understand it is nonrefundable. So was the leg.

Interest is charged at your rate, not mine: seven percent, compounded daily, which is what you charge me when I am late. I assumed you would want to be treated the way you treat others.

Terms are net 30. I have no evidence that you will pay. I have no evidence that you will read this. A bill that is never sent is not a bill; it is a feeling, and I have enough of those. So I am sending it. One settles accounts before leaving. It is the only part of the arrangement I still believe in.

Yours, from the exit,

Omar Nabil Metwally, MD, physician-dissident

II. The Invoice

FINAL INVOICE. Account closed at the customer’s request.

Invoice no.1095-R. The R is for refund.
FromOmar Nabil Metwally, MD, Ypsilanti, Michigan. You have the address. You write to it every January.
ToThe United States of America, c/o Department of the Treasury, 1500 Pennsylvania Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20220
CopyHealth Insurance Marketplace, 465 Industrial Boulevard, London, Kentucky 40750-0001, the return address on every form cited below
DateOctober 21, 2026
TermsNet 30. Due November 20, 2026.

Diagnosis codes, ICD-10-CM. These are real. You can bill for them. I am.

  • Z59.7 — Insufficient social insurance and welfare support
  • Z59.86 — Financial insecurity
  • Z75.3 — Unavailability and inaccessibility of health-care facilities
  • Y69 — Unspecified misadventure during surgical and medical care

Proposed for the next revision. Submitted to CMS by the usual route, which is to say, posted here.

  • Z00.USA — Receipt of the most expensive healthcare on earth; value received, unspecified. Patient believes that paying more means getting more. Patient has not been told otherwise.

Statement

Tax yearMonths coveredPremiums I paid, net of your creditsHealth share of my federal income tax, 31.2%Interest, 7% compounded daily from Dec 31Line total
2018May–Dec$1,708.72$4,495.92$4,514.30$10,718.94
2021Jan–Mar$941.16$5,854.99$2,719.13$9,515.28
2022Jan–Sep$1,173.78$3,221.71$1,342.61$5,738.10
2023Jan–Dec$1,519.32$5,521.15$1,529.22$8,569.69
2024Jan–Dec$6,728.16$6,908.30$1,836.88$15,473.34
2025Jan–Dec$7,879.20$9,273.89$994.84$18,147.93
Subtotal$19,950.34$35,275.96$12,936.98$68,163.28

Other items

ItemAmount
Global Entry fee, nonrefundable$120.00
Right leg, one, previously functionalNot billed here. That invoice goes to someone else.

TOTAL DUE: $68,283.28

Notes

  1. Premiums are Column A less Column C of each year’s Form 1095-A: $39,312.34 billed by the plans, of which you paid $19,362.00 in advance credits. Thank you. The years not listed were employer coverage, taken out of my paycheck before I saw it, which is a different invoice.
  2. Federal income tax is the total-tax line of each year’s Form 1040, $113,064 across the six years. The 31.2 percent is the share of federal spending that went to health programs in 2025, by the Tax Foundation’s reading of OMB’s historical tables. I have applied the 2025 share to every year. It was lower before the pandemic. You may dispute it. I would welcome the correspondence.
  3. Interest is 7 percent, compounded daily: the rate you set for individuals for the quarter beginning October 1, 2026 (IR-2026-98). It runs from December 31 of each year, not from the month each premium was paid, so it undercounts. You’re welcome.

III. Terms

  1. Payment is due in 30 days. After that, the balance accrues the penalty you charge me when I am late: one half of one percent per month, to a maximum of 25 percent, with interest on the penalty. I did not invent these numbers. I copied them from your website.
  2. Payment may be made by check, wire, or yacht. I used to pride myself on having no debt. I am now running an experiment to see how much medical debt a human can carry.
  3. Remit to the address on file. I will not be sending the Washtenaw County Sheriff to collect the house and my two cars (including my wife’s car, which is under my name). I understand that is your move, and I would not want to deprive you of it.
  4. Disputes may be submitted in writing. I will read them from abroad, somewhere with hospitals, where the premiums are called taxes and the taxes buy a hospital. I will not be taking calls. I have spent enough of my life on hold.
  5. This account will not be renewed. Please stop writing to me in January.

IV. A Note on Delivery

This invoice is not being filed with the Internal Revenue Service. I looked into it. A return or refund claim the Service finds frivolous carries a penalty of $5,000 under section 6702, which reaches any submission that “reflects a desire to delay or impede the administration of Federal tax laws.” I have no such desire. I have a desire to be paid. But I am a physician, not a lawyer, and I have learned what it costs to find out what a sentence means. So the one safe way to send my government a bill is not to send it, and to post it here instead, where it will be read by the only people who were ever going to read it.

To them I will say one thing, and then I will go. You are not getting what you pay for. You never were. Here, the more you pay, the more you have paid.

Thank you for the opportunity.

FIN

Sources

  • Forms 1095-A for tax years 2018 and 2021 through 2025, and the total-tax line of the Forms 1040 for the same years. Mine.
  • Tax Foundation, The Spiraling Cost of Federal Healthcare Subsidies and Carveouts, September 2026: federal health spending of $2.18 trillion in 2025, 31.2 percent of the federal budget, from OMB’s historical tables.
  • IRS, IR-2026-98, August 21, 2026: 7 percent, compounded daily, for individual underpayments in the quarter beginning October 1, 2026.
  • IRS, Failure to Pay Penalty: 0.5 percent of unpaid tax per month, up to 25 percent, with interest charged on penalties.
  • 26 U.S.C. § 6702: a $5,000 civil penalty for frivolous tax returns and specified frivolous submissions.
  • Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker, How does health spending in the U.S. compare to other countries?, March 11, 2026: $14,775 per person in the United States in 2024, against $7,860 in comparable countries.
  • Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker, How does U.S. life expectancy compare to other countries?, March 31, 2026: 79.0 years in the United States in 2024, against 82.7 in comparable countries, the lowest among peer countries for both women and men.
  • ICD-10-CM: Z59.7, Z59.86, Z75.3 and Y69 are real, billable codes, titles as AAPC lists them. Z00.USA is not. Yet.

Leave a Reply